Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette – Reviews, Photos & Swatches

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase.

A holiday palette she’ll love more than her classic rock faves

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette photos: we heart this

Time is almost up for holiday shopping, and we’ve got one last limited edition holiday 2012 set that will have her singing with joy. Take a gander at Anastasia Beverly Hills Want You To Want Me Eye Shadow Paletteicon ($34), a luxe nude and plum eye shadow kit that had me rocking with glee.

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette packaging

Just one look at the plush packaging was all it took to have this palette rocket to the top of my must-have chart. Nestled inside the basic black and gold chained graphic box is a double CD sized black velvet box with a golden magnetic clasp closure engraved with the Anastasia Beverly Hills insignia.

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette

Unclasp this package to reveal the goodies: a 9 Shade Eyeshadow Palette, a mini Liquid Eyeliner, a mini Clear Brow Gel and a Double-ended Shadow Brush, as well as a large, high quality mirror attached to the flip up lid.

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette

As a lover of pretty, shiny things, I was immediately drawn to the palette of eye shadows. Included in this set of 9 rock inspired shadows are a range of browns and plums with both matte and shimmery finishes. The deep wine and lilac hues fulfill my holiday drama needs, while the nude and cocoa browns will carry me all through the year.

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette

The rock-n-roll named, gorgeous shadows alone are enough to get my endorsement, and we’ll get to the swatches in a minute. But first I want to talk about the mini sized “extras” included with the palette of my dreams.

Mini Clear Brow Gel and a Mini Liquid Eye Liner

Anastasia Beverly Hills is renowned for their incredible eye and brow products, end the eye enhancing items in the Want You To Want Me palette, a Mini Clear Brow Gel and a Mini Liquid Eye Liner in Jet are no exception.

The Clear Brow Gel applies smoothly with a mascara-like wand, brushing my brows in shape and then setting them into place. My slightly unruly brows are tamed into submission with a subtle sheen that adds some drama – all without any sticky or crunchy residue. It’s the holy grail of brow gels, my friends.

Mini Clear Brow Gel and a Mini Liquid Eye Liner brush

Meanwhile, the Liquid Eye Liner in Jet is a deep, inky black with fabulous pigmentation. The thin brush applicator allows for precise lining and the formula goes on the lids super smooth. Even better, it stays on the lids. Even after a night of wear, my oily lids were no match for this liner and I was smudge and flake free. A true victory for me.

small brush

Even the mini sized Duel-ended Brush is a rock star. At first, the teeny sized brush seemed like the throw away of the kit. But I love how the small brush heads fit perfectly into the shadow pans, and was impressed with their softness and spot-on application powers.

Speaking of shadows, are you ready to take a peak at the colors in action?

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette swatches

Platform Wedge – medium nude matte

Front Row Center – light champagne shimmer

Ziggy – light grape with silver shimmer

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette swatches

Members Only – medium mushroom brown matte

Power Ballad – medium brown shimmer

Jellies – medium pink shimmer

Anastasia Want You to Want Me Palette swatches

Graphic T’s – dark chocolate brown with gold shimmer

Brass In Pocket – light bronzey brown shimmer

Iron On – blackened plum with purple micro glitter

And all the way to the right is Jet, the inky black liquid liner

As you can see all nine shades mix and match well. Currently, I love to wear Power Ballad on my lids, with Ziggy blended into the crease and a dusting of Front Row Center on the brow bone. And I must note that Graphic T’s has quickly become my daily, go-to brown shadow. It’s a great not quite matte deep brown with the perfect touch of shimmer.

Overall, the Anastasia Want You To Want Me Eye Shadow Paletteicon is definite hit. So if you’re looking for a last-minute gift that she is sure to want, need and love, I recommend braving the crowds and hitting your local Sephora to pick up this gem.

we heartsters – do you want, need and love this gift palette too?

Disclosure: This review includes products that were provided by the manufacturer/PR firm for our consideration. It also contains an affiliate link, a link that gives us a small commission if you purchase the item. For more info, or any questions, please see our disclosure policy.


  • tyna

    Tyna is a former editor of we heart this that worries about becoming a crazy cat lady, reads at least a book a week, checks in at a Flyers fan forum every morning and is forever organizing her closets and drawers. skin tone: NW 20/25 skin type: combination favorite beauty product: eye shadows and lip balms


  1. *Gasp* Those eye shadow colors are gorgeous and I want all of them, but that packaging is sooooo awesome!! I love the gold chain design!!

    1. We saved one of the best for last @kari – this one is gasp-worthy! And I’m totally a sucker for the witty rock themed names as well.

  2. Lovely colors in this palette! Great packaging/decor. The letters look so cute!

  3. Who would not look great in this palette? I love that packaging, too. I’ve only ever tried brow products from Anastasia but it seems like shadows would be a natural segue. Pretty!

  4. the packaging… is beautiful

    1. It sure is @Anne – and you’ve only seen the pictures! it’s even better in person, and I love the feel of the CD sized velvet box…le sigh. The whole thing just makes me happy.

  5. And now I’ve found what to spend my Sephora gift card on. THESE ARE GORGEOUS! Jellies is just calling out my name…and the packaging. Done and done.
    Now the question is, do I brave the malls tomorrow on the Saturday before Christmas or wait until afterwards? Hmm….

    1. Happy to help you put that Sephora card to good use @lyssachelle! You will love this set. And I say brave the crowds – it’s worth it!

  6. Gorgeous palette, @tyna , and the extras make it irresistible. I totally agree about the brow gel, which is my favorite brow product of all time. I literally use it every single day!

  7. I was lucky to get this at Nordstrom Rack recently for around $15. It is a great compact . (I am very partial to pallets that have lots of colors in one central location.) Now that I have had this awhile, my least favorite components are the ones with micro glitter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *