This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase.
With the top Urban Decay setting spray alternatives, you can enjoy the same level of performance but at a fraction of the cost.
We’re not saying you need to chuck out the Urban Decay All Nighter. This iconic setting spray has a permanent HG status in our makeup collection, after all.
However, it’s still good to find affordable setting spray alternatives that are perfect for day-to-day wear. You might even discover a new holy grail product for creating a flawless finish.
In this article, we’ve rounded out the top UD All Nighter alternatives, so you don’t have to waste time on duds.
Keep reading to find the top Urban Decay setting spray replacement for you!
How to Choose the Top Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray Alternative
To find the best alternative, we need to break down what makes the Urban Decay All Nighter so special in the first place.
Here are the factors you need to consider when choosing the top Urban Decay setting spray alternative.
- Formula: The Urban Decay setting spray has an alcohol base, which is what helps seal the makeup in place. It also features patented technology that lowers the temperature of your makeup to make it smudge-proof, water-resistant, and transfer-proof.
- Wear time: With incredible staying power, it can keep your makeup in place for up to 16 hours.
- Finish: The UD All Nighter has a matte finish that makes skin look naturally smooth and flawless.
- Notable features: The Urban Decay setting spray is cruelty-free and vegan. It has aloe extract that helps soothe the skin. It also has tocopherol, an antioxidant with anti-inflammatory properties. It does not contain parabens or mineral oil.
- Scent: The Urban Decay setting spray contains fragrance, which can irritate some. However, the faint chemical scent does go away after application.
- Suitable for: All skin types. However, the alcohol base may be too harsh or irritating for those with dry and sensitive skin.
13 Top Urban Decay Setting Spray Alternatives
It is virtually the same product as Urban Decay setting spray but cheaper!
Key benefits: Up to 16 hours of wear; matte finish; controls shine; vegan and cruelty-free
- Slow evaporation technology to lock in makeup from day to night
- Absorbs excess oil so makeup doesn’t look greasy
- Lightweight and breathable formula for your comfort
You’ll feel confident with the all-day flawless finish of the Skindinavia Makeup Oil Control Finishing Spray.
This is the perfect Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray alternative, which isn’t surprising since the Skindinavia Makeup Oil Control Finishing Spray is made by the same manufacturer.
It’s not the most affordable alternative, but you’ll still get more per wear. Even better, the Skindinavia setting spray holds your makeup for up to 16 hours.
It features the same temperature control technology as the Urban Decay setting spray that controls shine and prevents makeup from fading.
As such, you’ll get a flawless matte finish that lasts from day to night.
The Skindinavia Makeup Oil Control Finishing Spray has an oil-free and hypoallergenic formula. It is suitable for all skin types, especially those with oily and dehydrated skin.
This budget-friendly Urban Decay All Nighter alternative delivers high-quality performance.
Key benefits: Long-lasting up to 16 hours; matte finish; transfer-proof; absorbs oil; vegan and cruelty-free
- Keeps makeup intact and doesn’t settle into fine lines
- Reduces the appearance of shine for a non-greasy makeup look
- Water-based formula is quickly absorbed into the skin
The NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray – Matte Finish has a cult following of its own.
You don’t have to splurge for the top Urban Decay setting spray replacement.
The NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish is so much more affordable. Nonetheless, it delivers the same long-lasting hold as the Urban Decay All Nighter.
Your makeup won’t budge even as you sweat or wear a mask on top.
The lightweight setting spray even has niacinamide to help control oil production, giving you a non-greasy matte look. The water-based formula prevents makeup from settling into fine lines or dry patches.
This is a perfect Urban Decay setting spray alternative for oily skin, but the setting spray also works on all skin types.
With great versatility, this budget-friendly alternative gives the Urban Decay setting spray a run for its money.
This UD All Nighter alternative does so much more than just set your makeup.
Key benefits: Up to 16 hours of hold; illuminating finish; hydrating formula; vegan and cruelty-free
- Primes, corrects, and sets to enhance your makeup application
- Long-lasting hold that doesn’t crease, smudge, or fade
- Hydrating formula feels refreshing on the skin
The Milani Make It Last 3-in-1 setting spray gives an all-around flawless makeup finish.
If you find the Urban Decay setting spray a little too matte, consider the Milani Make It Last 3-in-1 setting spray as your alternative.
It has an illuminating formula that gives your skin a healthy, radiant glow. Like Urban Decay, this setting spray replacement can last up to 16 hours of wear.
Going beyond that, the Milani setting spray primes and corrects. This further enhances your makeup application, ensuring it doesn’t budge or smudge. It also helps reduce the appearance of imperfections.
To meet your skin’s needs, this fan-favorite setting spray has a Charcoal variant that controls oil and mattifies skin and a Dewy variant that brightens and hydrates.
With just one spray, you can slay — thanks to a flawless makeup finish that lasts from day to night.
This Urban Decay setting spray alternative is a well-kept secret among professional makeup artists — until now!
Key benefits: Matte, smudge-proof finish; waterproof formula; extended wear time
- Alcohol-based formula to ensure that makeup is completely sealed
- Won’t smudge or melt under hot stage lights or underwater
- Mint scent provides cooling sensation
Oil and sweat are no match for the Ben Nye Final Seal setting spray.
When it comes to sealing your makeup, the Ben Nye Final Seal even outperforms the Urban Decay All Nighter setting spray.
It’s ideal for special events such as weddings or performances where you can’t be bothered with constant touch-ups.
This Urban Decay All Nighter alternative has a long-lasting matte finish. Your makeup won’t budge with excess oils, sweat, and humidity — or even if you decide to swim underwater!
As a bonus, there’s also a minty scent that gives a cooling sensation upon application.
Overall, you get even better performance for a fraction of the cost, making this one of the best Urban Decay setting spray replacements.
This drugstore alternative for Urban Decay Setting Spray will make you look fresh even hours after application.
Key benefits: Lightweight, oil-free formula; soft matte finish; keeps makeup fresh up to 24 hours; non-comedogenic and dermatologist-tested
- Locks in makeup without smudging, melting, or creasing
- Delivers a micro-fine mist that feels weightless on skin
- Controls shine for a natural but flawless finish
Say goodbye to midday touch-ups with the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Pro-Spray & Set Makeup Setting Spray.
Like the Urban Decay setting spray, the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Pro-Spray & Set will lock in your makeup for all-day wear.
You don’t have to worry about your makeup caking or settling into fine lines.
With the smudge-proof formula, you can forgo midday touchups in your daily makeup routine. You’ll look just as fresh as when you first applied your makeup.
The setting spray also has an ultra-lightweight mist that ensures an even finish. It may feel tacky initially, but the formula dries quickly and leaves a soft matte finish.
The L’Oreal Paris Infallible Pro-Spray & Set Makeup Setting Spray suits all skin types. There is a faint scent that goes away after a while, but it’s still worth considering for those with sensitivities.
This All Nighter Setting Spray alternative from e.l.f. will hold your makeup from a.m. to p.m.
Key benefits: Up to 16 hours of wear; semi-matte finish; hydrating formula; vegan and cruelty-free
- Keeps makeup fresh and flawless for the entire day
- Micro-fine mister for even coverage and seamless application
- Infused with cucumber, aloe, and green tea extract to nourish the skin
The e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist also helps you achieve flawless skin from within.
As an affordable alternative to the Urban Decay setting spray, the e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist provides a lot of value for its price.
This setting spray locks in your makeup for up to 16 hours without needing to blot or touch up. It has a semi-matte finish that makes you look fresh and radiant even at the end of the day.
There is also a microfine mister that makes application smooth and easy.
Best of all, the setting spray works behind the scenes to enhance your complexion. It is infused with cucumber, aloe, and green tea extract that nourishes and soothes skin in the long run.
Thanks to the e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist, you can create flawless makeup looks without going over the budget.
Bella Jade offers an organic alternative to the Urban Decay setting spray.
Key benefit: Gentle, non-irritating formula; dewy finish; airbrushed look all day or night; vegan and cruelty-free
- Achieve airbrushed makeup looks that last all day or night
- Featherlight mist helps hydrate and revitalize your skin
- Enriched with organic green tea, white tea, MSM, and sodium PCA
Enriched with botanical ingredients, the Bella Jade Makeup Setting Spray also delivers anti-aging skin benefits.
Since setting spray stays on our skin all day, we might as well choose one that can deliver anti-aging benefits, right?
As an Urban Decay All Nighter alternative, the Bella Jade Makeup Setting Spray can hold makeup for the entire day or night.
Whether you’re attending a formal gala or just going on Zoom meetings, you’ll look flawless and airbrushed. It also leaves a natural and dewy glow.
As an organic setting spray, the hydrating formula is also gentle and non-irritating. The fine mist also feels light and refreshing on the skin.
The Bella Jade Makeup Setting Spray is suitable for all skin types but especially for those with tight and dehydrated skin.
The Mac Prep + Prime Fix+ is a hydrating alternative for setting spray.
Key benefits: Improves makeup wear for up to 12 hours; hydrating, alcohol-free formula; dewy finish; dermatologist-tested and non-acnegenic
- Preps, primes, and sets makeup for a flawless look
- Can be used before, during, or after makeup application
- Infused with chamomile, cucumber and green tea extract to soothe and hydrate skin
This Urban Decay All Nighter alternative will be a versatile addition to your makeup kit.
There really is no debate when it comes to Urban Decay All Nighter vs MAC Fix Plus. Both setting sprays have “holy grail” status among makeup lovers, after all.
However, consider the MAC Fix Plus as an alternative if you want something more versatile.
It helps create a smooth base for an even makeup application. You can also use it to correct makeup mistakes and intensify the color of your makeup pigments.
To lock everything in, the MAC Fix Plus melts makeup so the different layers blend naturally and seamlessly. This works more as a finishing spray than Urban Decay All Nighter, creating a waterproof “shield” over your makeup.
Nonetheless, the result is still a fresh and flawless look lasting up to 12 hours. It leaves a dewy finish and won’t look cakey for the rest of the day.
You can also spritz the MAC Fix Plus anytime for a boost of hydration. It contains chamomile, green tea, and cucumber that feel refreshing and soothing for the skin.
The Rimmel London Stay Matte Fix & Go has a hybrid formula to both prime and set your face.
Key benefits: Locks in makeup all day; controls shine; matte finish; oil-free and quick-dry formula
- Keeps makeup vibrant and radiant even hours after application
- Dries quickly with a transparent shine-free finish
- Infused with cucumber extract to soothe and revive the skin
As a 2-in-1 product, you can use this Urban Decay setting spray alternative before and after makeup application.
The Rimmel London Stay Matte Fix & Go Setting Spray is perfect for those without much time for makeup application.
The hybrid formula acts as a primer and setting spray in one. The formula also dries quickly, so you’re out the door in no time!
This UD All Nighter setting spray alternative will keep everything in place for the entire day. It leaves a matte and radiant finish that’s completely invisible in direct lighting or flash photography.
Best of all, the Rimmel London Stay Matte Fix & Go suits all skin types.
Not the most affordable replacement for the setting spray from UD. Still, it has added benefits that make it a worthy contender for the Urban Decay All Nighter.
Key benefits: Up to 24 hours of wear; water-resistant and transfer-proof; hydrating formula; natural finish; vegan and cruelty-free
- Instantly grips to makeup and lasts for up to 24 hours
- Budge-proof and doesn’t settle into fine lines
- Infused with witch hazel, allantoin, and willow leaf extract to soothe skin
The Dermablend Lock and Last Setting Spray creates a strong and instant grip to your makeup, keeping everything smudge-proof and transfer-resistant for up to 24 hours.
You won’t have to worry about your makeup creasing, caking, or fading for literally the whole day. Even with accidental splashes, you’ll still look flawless and natural.
With witch hazel, allantoin, and willow leaf extract, this setting spray instantly hydrates the skin. It feels refreshing even if you’re wearing a full face of makeup.
The formula is non-comedogenic, fragrance-free, phthalate-free, and allergy-tested. As such, this setting spray is suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin.
It’s always worth checking out a K-beauty alternative for the Urban Decay setting spray.
Key benefits: Locks down makeup for all-day wear; soft matte finish; oil control; cruelty-free and paraben-free
- Seals makeup in place for long-lasting and fade-proof wear
- Has oil control to keep face from becoming slick and greasy
- Feels weightless on the skin
Say goodbye to oil slicks with the Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Setting Spray.
We couldn’t cap off the list without including a K-beauty replacement for the Urban Decay setting spray.
The Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Setting Spray helps enhance your makeup application. It locks everything down, so you don’t have to worry about smudging, creasing, or fading throughout the day.
You’re able to enjoy a flawless, soft matte finish. The oil control properties ensure you don’t feel like an oil slick.
Instead, this setting spray replacement feels weightless on the skin. The skin-friendly formula also doesn’t contain parabens and sulfates to protect your skin in the long term.
A Flawless Finish With the Top Urban Decay Setting Spray Alternative
As amazing as the Urban Decay setting spray is, it’s also great to have budget-friendly alternatives in our makeup collection that we can use on rotation.
As you can see from this list, Urban Decay setting spray alternatives are just as capable in keeping your makeup in place. Some even have bonus features such as oil control, hydrating ingredients, and anti-aging benefits.
No matter which Urban Decay All Nighter setting spray alternative you choose, you’ll be able to get a flawless finish that lasts from day to night!
Want to Discover More Affordable Makeup Alternatives?
Check out these articles: